Pink Grapefruit Pie

Still rocking the free Rio Star grapefruits I got from TexaSweet, I started thinking about some grapefruit pie.

I searched high and low until my fingers fell off and my eyes started bleeding, but the only recipes I could find for “grapefruit pie” involved strawberry gelatin. While I’m sure that’s a great recipe – why else would it be ALL OVER the internet – I was imagining something more like a fruit custard, and less like a Jell-O mold.


Then a recalled a conversation I’d had recently about buttermilk pie.

It was all gravy after that. Couple experiments, each more yummier than the last, and blammo, Grapefruit Buttermilk Pie. I know it sounds a little weird maybe, but as my li’l brother pointed out, it tastes like Froot Loops and Froot Loops are good. Don’t embarrass yourself by denying that.

Plus the inside of the pie is naturally pink and that’s cute as hell.

4.7 from 3 reviews

Pink Grapefruit Pie
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Buttermilk pie with grapefruit
Author:
Serves: 8
Ingredients
  • 1 deep dish pie crust, unbaked
  • 2 eggs
  • 2 teaspoons grapefruit zest
  • ½ teaspoon lemon zest
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • ½ cup milk
  • ¾ cup red grapefruit juice, fresh (about 1 grapefruit)
  • 1 stick butter, melted (8 tablespoons; ¼ pound)
  • 3 tablespoons flour
  • For garnish: 1 grapefruit cut into segments (supremes)
Instructions
  1. Preheat the oven to 400 F
  2. Prick the bottom of the crust all over with a fork.
  3. Beat the eggs in a large bowl.
  4. Brush a little of the eggs over the bottom of the crust and put into the oven for 5 minutes to pre-bake.
  5. Add the zest and sugar to the eggs and mix well. Add the milk, juice, and butter and mix.
  6. While whisking, sprinkle to flour in until all is combined well.
  7. Pour into the hot crust and bake about 40 minutes, until a knife inserted in the middle comes out clean.
  8. Let cool completely and garnish with grapefruit segments.

If you liked this recipe, you’ll probably also like Classic Key Lime Pie!

Comments

  1. Love love love Rio Star grapefruit. Can’t wait to try your pie. The new Momofuku Milk Bar cookbook has a grapefruit & passionfruit pie that is absolutely divine!

    • Ooh, Annmartina, that pie sounds wonderful! I should get a copy of that book.
      Hope you like this recipe! Let me know if you post any pictures anywhere.
      -hilah

  2. I hate grapefruit, but this pie does sound yummy. Do you think this would work with oranges? (Or would that likely not curdle the milk the same way since the acidity is less?)

    • Hi Katie!
      I think this would work great with oranges! I bet lemon or lime would be nice, too, but you might need to add a touch more sugar with those.
      Happy cooking!
      -hilah

  3. I was born and raised in the Rio Grande Valley. I love Rio Star grapefruit!

  4. Arron Umberger says:

    I just stumbled upon this while browsing your site, and I must say it looks divine. I’m definitely going to have to try this. I love citrus and custard together – my favorite desert is key lime pie – so this sounds like a real winner to me.

  5. Annie Rousis says:

    I manage a little cafe in KC called You Say Tomato. We made this for the counter last week and received RAVE reviews. The first one came from me. Awesome recipe, thanks! Have you ever made the Brown Derby Grapefruit Cake? It’s one of our best selling cakes. Thanks again! Annie (P.S. Jane Almirall is my bud. She turned me onto you and I’m forever grateful.)

    • Hi Annie! That is so cool! I’m totally going to quote you on that. I am pretty positive no restaurant has every made and served anything of mine to their patrons. I’ve never even heard of the Brown Derby Grapefruit Cake. I’ll have to look it up while grapefruits are still kickin’.
      PS I love Jane!!! xoxo

  6. Made this today (in addition to your pie crust) for my parents. Dad said it was a home run, yo! Thanks for the grub.

  7. There is wrong Video, from Valentine’s day recipe!

  8. Love your show! This reminded me of a dish that a former roommate’s mom always makes for Thanksgiving: pink grapefruit salad. Essentially, it’s grapefruit supremes — was that the word? — suspended in some gelatin with sour cream and sugar swirls. As I write this, I realize it sounds really grandma-y church potluck-y, but it was so good! I ate almost all of it and never got invited back.

  9. I read an interesting tip today. If you put a whole grapefruit in boiling water for 5 minutes, remove it and cool. You can peel it, and the sour pith comes off with the peel. Just thought I’d share. Haven’t tried it yet.

  10. Caleb Valdez says:

    I have never had a citrus pie (other than Key Lime Pie), but this was a creamy, citrusy, delicious delight! And also very refreshing! (Who would’ve thought a pie could be so refreshing?) I didn’t have any grapefruit on hand, so I replaced it with a mix of orange and pomelo juice/zest. Still a great pie, but I will have to try and find Rio Star, if they’re sold here in Cali. I also posted a picture of a slice on Instagram if you wanna see it. (Username: kalbiv123)

    Thanks for the wonderful recipe, and for being so awesome!

    • Hi Caleb!
      I’m so glad you tried it out with other citrus fruits! I saw your picture on IG and it looked marvelous. :)
      Thanks for writing with your version and for sharing a picture!
      -h

  11. Hi hilah I was wondering if I can make this recipe with a gram cracker crust?

    • Hi Emma,
      I think that would work. The crust might get a little dark and possibly too toasted with the 40 minutes cook time, so you might want to lower the oven temperature by 25 degrees.

Leave a Comment

*

Rate this recipe: