Halloween Punch with Eyeballs

Here’s a boozy tequila punch for Halloween! The eyeballs are optional, but who wouldn’t want a couple of popped-out eyeballs floating around in their Halloween punch? Right?

If you’re having a kids’ Halloween party, you obviously don’t want to give them a bunch of liquor (or do you?) but here are a few not-crazy-sugary non-alcoholic Halloween punch ideas you can make and still use the “eyeballs”.

1. Equal parts Ginger Ale and Apple Juice makes a nicely beige punch that highlights these eyeballs well
2. Equal parts Seltzer and White Grape juice with some frozen green grapes and kiwi cubes makes a nice “green goo”
3. Orange juice and Grape juice (plus some seltzer) makes a murky brown “Swamp” punch with some gummy worms or leeches added
4. Cranberry juice with seltzer and a few scoops of raspberry sherbet and some eyeballs floating in it makes a “Blended-up Brains” punch for kids and adults who aren’t easily grossed out

Halloween Punch and Eyeballs demo video

Halloween Punch Recipe – Printable!

Halloween Punch with Eyeballs

Print Recipe

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

No reviews

• Author: Hilah Johnson
• Yield: 10 1x

Ingredients

Scale 1x2x3x

• 4 parts grapefruit juice
• 2 parts reposado tequila
• 1 part orange liqueur
• 1 part elderflower liqueur
• 6–8 parts seltzer water
• Eyeballs:
• 1 can lychee fruit
• 1 jar marachino cherries

Cook Mode Prevent your screen from going dark

Instructions

1. Combine all punch ingredients in a bowl or pitcher. Chill.
2. Drain lychee fruit and cut cherries in halves.
3. Stuff a cherry half into a lychee fruit. Place on plastic-covered plate and freeze until solid.
4. Drop frozen “eyeballs” into punch.
5. Serve.

Notes

For my punch I used a half-cup measure = 1 “part”

Check out these other easy Halloween Recipes!